When it comes to collecting U.S. quarters, most people encounter a sea of common coins in pocket change. However, among the vast number of state quarters in circulation, some stand out as valuable treasures. While most modern quarters are worth only face value, there are a few rare varieties and proof coins that can fetch significant amounts of money. In this article, we’ll explore some of the most valuable and collectible U.S. quarters you might find.
1. 1999-P Delaware Spitting Horse Quarter: $10 to $20
This Article Includes
- 1 1. 1999-P Delaware Spitting Horse Quarter: $10 to $20
- 2 2. 2004-D Extra Leaf Wisconsin Quarter: $50 to $65
- 3 3. 2005-P Minnesota Doubled Die Quarter: $5 to $100
- 4 4. 2009-D District of Columbia Doubled Die Quarter: $75
- 5 5. 1999-S Pennsylvania Proof Silver Quarter: $35
- 6 6. 1999-S New Jersey Proof Silver Quarter: $30
- 7 Conclusion
The 1999-P Delaware quarter is part of the first series of state quarters released, and among its many varieties, the “Spitting Horse” variety is the most sought after. This error coin features a prominent die break that creates a raised line extending from the horse’s mouth to the letters “CAESAR” on the reverse side. This defect, thought to be caused by a broken die, resembles a horse “spitting,” hence the name.
While initially rare, the Spitting Horse variety has become more common over the years, which has lowered its market value. Despite this, collectors still value it between $10 and $20 today, making it a fun and affordable find for any collector of state quarters.
2. 2004-D Extra Leaf Wisconsin Quarter: $50 to $65
The 2004-D Extra Leaf Wisconsin quarter is another error coin that has attracted significant attention. This coin is known for two varieties of “extra leaves” found on the corn stalks on the reverse side. The two varieties are the Extra High Leaf and Extra Low Leaf, which display additional leaves in different locations near the wheel of cheese.
When these varieties were first discovered, they caused a sensation, with some coins selling for over $500. However, as more examples surfaced and interest declined, the prices settled to around $50 to $65 for circulated coins. Despite the price drop, the Extra Leaf Wisconsin quarters remain a valuable addition to any collection.
3. 2005-P Minnesota Doubled Die Quarter: $5 to $100
The 2005-P Minnesota quarter, part of the 50 State Quarters program, is famous for its multiple varieties of doubled dies. These errors involve extra details, such as ghost-like outlines of an additional spruce tree, on the reverse side of the coin.
Collectors have identified over 60 different doubled die varieties for this issue, with the most dramatic examples fetching between $50 and $100. More subtle varieties can still be worth anywhere from $5 to $25, depending on their visibility and the condition of the coin.
4. 2009-D District of Columbia Doubled Die Quarter: $75
The 2009-D District of Columbia quarter, part of a special series to commemorate Washington D.C. and U.S. territories, features jazz legend Duke Ellington on the reverse. Some of these quarters exhibit an extraordinary doubled die, which causes the letters “ELL” in Ellington’s name and the piano keys to appear doubled.
When these doubled die varieties were first discovered, they generated substantial excitement among collectors, with some quarters fetching hundreds of dollars. While prices have cooled down, the 2009-D District of Columbia doubled die quarter can still be worth around $75 in circulated condition, making it a notable find for enthusiasts.
5. 1999-S Pennsylvania Proof Silver Quarter: $35
The 1999-S Pennsylvania quarter is part of the proof coin set released for collectors. Unlike standard circulation quarters, proof coins are struck multiple times for sharper details and have a mirror-like finish. The Pennsylvania quarter has a low mintage of only 804,565 coins and is composed of 90% silver, adding to its appeal among collectors.
The coin features a design with the state motto “VIRTUE, LIBERTY, INDEPENDENCE” and a depiction of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania’s outline. A flawless example of this coin typically sells for around $35, making it a solid addition to any proof coin collection.
6. 1999-S New Jersey Proof Silver Quarter: $30
Like the Pennsylvania quarter, the 1999-S New Jersey quarter is another proof coin struck from 90% silver. This coin features a historic design depicting George Washington crossing the Delaware River during the American Revolutionary War.
Proof coins, such as this one, are highly prized due to their superior quality and detailed finish. In perfect condition, the 1999-S New Jersey quarter can be worth about $30. For collectors interested in the U.S. states’ historic symbolism, this coin is a must-have.
Conclusion
While the vast majority of modern U.S. quarters are worth only face value, certain varieties and proof coins can be highly valuable. Whether it’s an error coin like the 1999-P Delaware Spitting Horse or a limited-edition proof coin such as the 1999-S Pennsylvania quarter, knowing which coins are rare can turn an ordinary pocket change discovery into a profitable find. Always keep an eye out for these special varieties, as they can make a significant difference to your coin collection’s value.